Guidance for Assessing the Work

No.	Aspect of writing skill	Questions	Peer’s comment
1.	Text organizations Did the writer choose an appropriate title? Score : 1 Did the text have a complete structure? (orientation, sequence of event(s), re-orientation) Score : 1 Did orientation state topic clearly? (who, what, when, and where the story happened) Score : 1 Were the events stated in sequential order? Score : 1 Did each paragraph have elaboration (supporting sentences) in order to make the reader understand the writer’s story better? Score: 1 Total Score : 5	If not what is your suggestion? If not, what should be added? If no, what is missing? If not, what should it be? Give the reason If not, add some supporting sentences
2.	Content Did the text develop clear idea? Clear : 5 Rather clear : 4 Confusing : 3 Idea is not connected : 2 Idea is out of topic : 1 Total Score : 5	If not, what it should be? Give the reason
3.	Grammar Did the writer use past tenses correctly in recount text? 1-2 mistakes : 3 3-4 mistakes : 2 More than 4 mistakes : 1 Did the writer use linking words (then, next, later, after that, etc)? Common usage : 2 Rather usage : 1 Never usage : 0 Total score : 5	If not, mention the mistakes and correct it If not, what should it be? Give some suggestions.
4.	Punctuation Did the writer use correct punctuation? 1-2 mistakes : 3 3-4 mistakes : 2 More than 4 : 1 Did the writer use correct spelling? 1-2 mistakes : 2 3-4 mistakes : 1 Total score : 5	If not, correct it. If not, correct it.
5.	Style Did the writer use various vocabularies? Precise usage of vocabularies : 5 Attempt to use variety vocabularies : 4 Some vocabularies misused : 3 Inappropriate usage of vocabularies : 2 Error usage of vocabularies : 0 Total Score : 5	If not, what it should be? Give the reason.

You can click the example on how to write your comment here